Showing posts with label Camelback Consign & Design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Camelback Consign & Design. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 19, 2016

Once a Burns Victim, Still a Burns Victim (10/29/17)

October 29, 2017


The State of Arizona, represented by our Attorney General, essentially promised inaction on restitution for the civil fraud perpetrated by Michael S. Burns of Camelback Consign and Design. (See below.)

And inaction it has delivered. In full. 

Hats off to the Consignment Vampire and his co-conspirators. You got away with theft. And I guess Mike, at least, knew that he would - based on his conversations with me and those reported by the news media. 

I can't help but wonder. Would the result would have been the same had the winning AG run on the Democratic Party ticket? 

As it is, my experience suggests that the saga chronicled in this blog is just one of many, many more never reported and never appropriately resolved. Because, after all, why invest the time and effort in a system that simply doesn't deliver on a promise of "justice for all"?

Well, for those of us whose faith in the justice system is no more, perhaps faith in karma is the answer. 




October 19, 2016


Mr. Attorney General Brnovich: 

CAN YOU HEAR ME NOW? NOW? HOW ABOUT NOW?


Guess not. Bad connection. 

Well, the fact is, this time, I didn't actually call Attorney General Brnovich. Arizona's AG, turns out, doesn't listen to average citizens or victims, not even when they complain in unison.(See my post, Complaints, Complaints, Complaints.)  All I - or any other Burns victims - got for our considerable pain and inconvenience was nothing. So now I talk to myself in public. Like this.

More than a year after the Office of the Attorney General of Arizona sent me an email explaining how it had failed to help me - and oh so many others, by the way - to receive recompense in the form of justice or money from Camelback Consign and Design, I continue to hear from other victims, who wonder what justice or recompense they might expect.





Gosh. Reading new "old" complaints about Camelback Consign and Design reminds of the good "bad old days." That's when I thought that the Attorney General of Arizona might actually be compelled to serve and protect the good citizens of the state from a particularly nasty predator who came to be known as the "Consignment Vampire" aka Mike Burns. 


I just came across this excerpt from an campaign email for the former AG candidate, Mike Brnovich, from a New Times article





Nope. Public outrage at the fact that AG Mark Brnovich has failed to deliver any more justice than the Republican AG he replaced - at least in this so terribly egregious case - is nil. 

Does it make you feel better that his wife, Susan Brnovich, is a Superior Court judge up for reelection? Her Judicial Performance Commission Results, as reported in the state's 2016 General Election Publicity Pamphlet are excellent. Her lowest rating, for the categories Legal Ability, Integrity, Communication Skills, Judicial Temperament and Administrative Performance, from Litigant/Witness Responses (i.e., average citizens) is 97%!

Wow. 

On the one hand, I sorta wish Susan Brnovich's zeal would rub off on her husband. On the other, I gotta wonder if the result recorded reflects the complete apathy of all but one or two of the many (?) litigants and witnesses that were asked to provide a rating. 

Anyway.

I'm still on the look out for the following items that Mike and Justin Burns sold and failed to recompense me for:








---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FYI

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Anglen, Robert  (Arizona Republic & Call 12 for Action)
Date: Sun, Sep 28, 2014 at 9:40 AM
Subject: Story on camelback consign
To: Glenn Michaels  



Story is in today's paper. Your blog is mentioned prominently in the story. Thanks for all of your help. Here is a link:


http://www.azcentral.com/story/money/business/consumer/call-12-for-action/2014/09/28/missing-painting-returned-owner/16373445/






Tuesday, November 10, 2015

SUPERIOR COURT JUDGMENTS SHOW BAD JUDGEMENT

 For more details, see the blog posts listed at the bottom of this page.
Posted on November 10, 2015.


WHAT'S WRONG WITH THIS JUDGMENT?



On May 20, 2015, the Superior Court judgment rendered against Camelback Consign & Design LLC was added to the official records of the Maricopa County Recorder. On July 1, 2015, a separate Superior Court judgment against Michael S. Burns, was filed with county recorder's office.


The former states, as a conclusion of law, that 


"Defendent Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C. participated in, profited from and furthered a scheme of deceptive acts and practices in connection with the the sale of merchandise, thereby engaging in unlawful practices under the Arizona Consumer Fraud Act, A.R.S. 44-1521, et seq.

"While engaging in the acts and practices alleged above, Defendent Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C. acted willfully as defined by A.R.S.44-1531 (B)."

The latter duplicates the forgoing text, but replaces Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C.  with Michael S. Burns.


The judgment against Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C. states that it is now forbidden to engage in any and deceptive acts or practices, fraud, false pretense, false promises, misrepresentations, and/or concealment, suppression or omission of material fact in violation of the Arizona Consumer Fraud Act.

In short, it is henceforth forbidden to break the laws that it already broke. How's that for a firm stand against illegal activity?

The court awarded the State a judgment of $217,414.53 with interest of 4.25% annually, plus another $41,124.13 with interest of 4.25% annually for attorney's fees, to be deposited in the Consumer Protection - Consumer Fraud Revolving Fund. Finally, it also awarded a judgment of $250,000 with interest of 4.25% annually, as a civil penalty.

The total judgment amounts to $508, 538.66.

 The second judgment awarded the State, made Michael S. Burns, "jointly and severally" responsible with Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C. for the judgment of $217,414.53 with interest of 4.25% annually. The court added, as a civil penaty against Burns, another  $20,000 with interest of 4.25% annually. 

Thus, Michael S. Burns and Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C. owe the State a total of $528,538.66 at an interest rate of 4.25% annually. 

BAD JUDGMENT?


So what is so terrible about these admittedly high dollar penalties?

1. Michael S. Burns had several employees who worked with him for years. How is it possible that the State failed to charge these individuals as co-defendants?

2. One of the aforementioned employes was Justin Burns, who was eventually elevated to a managing member of Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C. How is it possible that a managing member of the firm and a participant in its business dealings over at least a year escaped any and all legal responsibility for the illegal actions of the firm?

3. The court had the ability, according to the Arizona Republic, to sanction Michael S. Burns by refusing him the right to own and operate a consignment business in the future. Why on earth would it allow him to return to the same line of work in which he had heartless plundered so many innocent victims?

4. The judgment neglects to reference exactly how the State intends to enforce this judgment.


###


Text of the Default Judgment as to 
Defendant Camelback Consign & Design, L.L.C.


















Text of the Default Judgment as to 
Defendant Michael S. Burns









---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FYI

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Anglen, Robert  (Arizona Republic & Call 12 for Action)
Date: Sun, Sep 28, 2014 at 9:40 AM
Subject: Story on camelback consign
To: Glenn Michaels  



Story is in today's paper. Your blog is mentioned prominently in the story. Thanks for all of your help. Here is a link:


http://www.azcentral.com/story/money/business/consumer/call-12-for-action/2014/09/28/missing-painting-returned-owner/16373445/